Forum Index » Guest Playbook » Madden Defensive Formation: Box Protect
Madden Defensive Formation: Box Protect
bobnoles Sun Jan 16, 2005 4:45 pm Madden Defensive Formation: Box Protect
Hey everyone!! Yeah, I am new to the forum.....but not to the website. Sweet website here, best for Madden Football I have seen.
I have come up with a defensive formation that I have tested extensively. I play all games against my own teams that I create, so the competition level is even. This formation has been tested in over 15 games and many situations within those games. It is called the Box Protect because it does a good job at stopping any short yardage plays anywhere within the box and around the edges. It places 9 players in the box and 2 corners outside. Here is what it looks like:
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....C.........C..... (Corners 3 & 4)
........L...L........ (MLB1 & MLB2)
C...................C (Corners 2 & 1)
....S..E..N..E..S....
^ ^ ^
SS1 DT1 SS2
It is somewhat vulnerable to passes over the middle. However, if you drop one of the linebackers into into a hook zone and spy WR 3 or 4 it compensates well. This formation is perfect for redzone. The only time in the 15 games I have used this in the redzone where this has been scored on was when the QB ran a sneak to the right or left of the nose tackle or a short slant route over the middle (which I have fixed in my latest plays by using LB hook zones) This formation is wonderful at stopping the run. 2 LB's in middle stuff runs up the gut and SS's stop sweeps and tosses of any sort as well as swing passes and screens. This is a good formation to use on 3rd & short when the opponent is just as likely to run a sweep as they are a dive. Corners 1 & 2 are always in man coverage, 3 & 4 play either man or Curl Flat zones most of the time. SS's can also blitz left or right.
Hope you all like this formation!
Later, B-Mac
P.S. I'll add some plays to this topic from my playbook later today.......
lazziness Mon Jan 17, 2005 4:11 am
Looks good, cant wait to see more
pimpdaddypat Mon Jan 17, 2005 6:08 am
it looks a little weak up the middle to me ... and how far outside are the SS's?
bobnoles Tue Jan 18, 2005 11:02 pm re:
@lazziness thanks, I hope to get some plays on here soon.
@pimpdaddypat Like I said, it is a little weak in the middle. However, if you drop a linebacker or 2, you can compensate for the lack of personnel in the middle. The SS's are right on the edges of the box so they can protect against pitches/sweeps/outside tackle runs as well as covering receivers in the slot. Hope that explains things a little better.
I'll get some plays on here soon, I have been really busy in the last two days and have a meeting tonight. Hopefully tomorrow afternoon.
lipidquadcab Tue Jan 18, 2005 11:28 pm
I like this formation a lot...seems like it would dominate in the red zone...also, having those safetys on the line make zone blitzes a very good possibility...makes me wonder, do you use the 46 a lot?
pimpdaddypat Wed Jan 19, 2005 3:59 am
well i actually like it also ... i might actually create it and try it ... another idea i had was to put 3 LB's instead of two and 3 corners instead of 4 and play a 3 deep, 5 under, and rush 3 ... like a 3-5-3 ... ive already made that defense and it is very effective against singleback formations
bobnoles Wed Jan 19, 2005 10:56 pm re:
I really don't use the 46 that often. I do have a 4-4 defense that I use that seems to work against anything with 2 WR's and up to 2 TE's, but other than that, I always have atleast 2 safeties back. However, only in the quarter do I drop my safeties more than 10 yards. I like to get all of my players in on every play and have them swarming to the ball on run plays, it doesn't work well with they are more than 10 yards back. I also have a 5-front formation, with 1 LB, a SS right and a FS back about 10 yards on the left. 2 corners left and 1 right. I haven't experimented with the 5 front very much yet.
I'll have to try your 3-5-3 pimpdaddypat. I am always looking for better defensive formations and plays.
Here are 3 basic plays from my box protect:
Play 1 assignments:
3 DLinemen= Base defense (the straight ahead blitz basically....)
Left SS= Blitz right
All 4 corners in man coverage
Right SS= Man coverage
Right Middle LB (sounds kind of strange I know!)= Base defense
Left Middle LB= Hook Zone, Spy WR 3
Play 2 assignments:
All corners and safeties in man coverage (provides for double coverage on, at the very least, one receiver)
Right MLB= Blitz Middle
Left MLB= Hook Zone Spy WR 3
Nose Tackle= Blitz right, provides for a pressure point on the left side of the OL with 3 rushers on 2 linemen
Play 3 assignments:
All Corners and Left SS in Man coverage
Right SS= QB Spy
RE & DT= Base defense
LE= Blitz Left
Left MLB= Blitz Left
Right MLB= Hook Zone, Spy WR 4
I'll add some more in the next few days if you guys want. These are the basic plays; no more than one blitzer, man coverage, many base defense commands amongst personnel, etc. I have some zone coverage as well as more aggresive plays I can include later.
pimpdaddypat Thu Jan 20, 2005 3:26 am
when i get a chance i will try these out
lipidquadcab Thu Jan 20, 2005 8:40 pm
well drats...I keep trying to find someone who loves the 46 as much as I do...oh well...
bobnoles Fri Jan 21, 2005 12:40 am
If anyone wants pictures of what this formation looks like in-game, let me know and I'll e-mail them to you.
Thanks
SouthTitanDude Sat Jan 22, 2005 5:28 am
I like it. Pretty original. Seems kinda like Arkaeins 3-4 peregrine.
Jesus saves!!!
Kody
<><Romans5:8<><
Arkaein Sat Jan 22, 2005 6:15 pm my thoughts
I've finally gotten a chance to try this out, and while I like some elements (good pass coverage and some nice blitzes) I don't really feel it is suitable to be a solid red zone or general purpose defense (at least not against a human, it may work well against the CPU which does not adapt to strategies well). Here's why:
- It's a Dime defense (6 DBs). It shuts down outside runs but gives up easy yards on simple dive plays.
- No deep zone. Even in the red zone, this can make a difference, especially when a Dive play gashes the D right up the middle.
- Players out of position. The front 7 is already spread thin against the run, and a few blitzes (LB to outside, NT away from middle) open up even bigger holes to run through.
- Too much man coverage. PA fakes can kill these guys deep and to the corners.
- Personnel choices. A dime defense where the starting FS is not even on the field, but a backup safety and 2 backup CBs are.
- Not enough variation between plays. All 3 rely primarily on man coverage.
All of these flaws were observed in practice mode on All-Pro at the 15 yard line. It did make a number of good plays, including a good number of sacks and INTs, so there is promise.
That said, I think there are things that can be done to improve the situation.
- Replace a deep CB with the FS, and the strongside SS with the LOLB (and maybe the right MLB with the ROLB, depending on whether you play using a team with a 3-4 or 4-3 base). This gets most of the normal starters on a team on the field, with 6 of the normal front 7 from either a 4-3 or a 3-4 team on the field with only one DB substitution. It adds bulk against the run and matches up a LB instead of a SS against the likely TE on the offense's strong side.
- Shift the LE and LOLB (or left SS) each in one square. This will shore up the most vulnerable running gap.
- Mix in some other coverages. Zones work well in the red zone because it's easy to ensure that the entire field is covered. Blitzes also tend to use zones more often because they expose fewer glaring holes.
I haven't tried these mods out yet, but I think they could help make Box Protect a more effective and less one-dimensional formation.
bobnoles Sat Jan 22, 2005 9:58 pm re:
I do have some plays off of the box protect that drop 5-6 guys into zone coverage, I just didn't list them in the forum. I never put the very outside corners in zone though, I refuse to let up easy passing yards underneath, I'd rather make the opponent work for the yardage. As far as replacing on or more of the SS's or CB's: I designed this formation for speed purposes and my teams always have SS's that can run with almost any receiver and tackle the strongest fullback....they are usually the 6-1/6-2 205-215 type, so they have some bulk and yet speed as well. In the redzone, it's all about quickness and the box protect puts speed on the field, changing those aspects would take away from its purpose. I usually don't use this defense right on the goal line or within a yard or 2 though because I do recognize the lack of defense against a dive play, and I as mentioned in my original post, the QB sneak/dive play.......
Arkaein Sat Jan 22, 2005 10:33 pm
A few more points...
Quote:
I never put the very outside corners in zone though, I refuse to let up easy passing yards underneath
There are plenty of ways to stop passes underneath with CBs in zone. In a Dime you can play the outside CBs in flats coverage or hook coverage, or you could slide out your SSs into flats coverage. Plus, I think it's bad to totally disregard a particular strategy. Man coverage can still let of easy yards underneath using crossing routes or possibly swings, and you can't cover everywhere at once so focusing up close all the time means that sooner or later your opponent will find consistent openings deep.
Quote:
In the redzone, it's all about quickness
I disagree. Quickness counts on all parts of the field, but in the red zoen you
must be able to stop power runs, and this requires bulk or blitz schemes designed to plug running lanes. As I said I ran practice reps from the 15 yard line, and a simple play like Strong-Off Tackle (HB follows offset FB and strong side TE) will easily get 5-10 yards on most plays, with an occasional walk in TD. The RG is completely uncoverage and can push directly forward to the LBs while the C and RT take on the NT and LE. The FB can pickup either of these two if they get through, and the TE can easily manhandle the SS and often can block downfield on a deep CB or double team the strong side LB. In your plays where either the NT or LB blitz
away from this gap it's even easier.
Like I said, this formation can make some plays but if I saw it I would just line up in a power running formation and jam the ball down the D's throat.
bobnoles Sun Jan 23, 2005 3:36 am re:
I have tried putting the outside corners into a hook zone, but it always lets up passes over the top so I have never saved any of those plays in my playbook......I think if I go and alter the box protect then it'll be too much like formations already establishedl; I want this formation to be a unique addition (if it were to be added) to your madden playbook.
Thanks anyway.
Forum Index » Guest Playbook » Madden Defensive Formation: Box Protect