Forum Index » Guest Playbook » Madden Defensive Formation: Box Protect

Madden Defensive Formation: Box Protect

Page 2 of 2: 1 2

Arkaein Sun Jan 23, 2005 5:13 am
Well, I think I'll try out some of my own suggestions in any case. I'm curious to see if I'm right, and the form won't be modified all that drastically (it'll be a type of 3-3-5 Nickel, which is pretty uncommon, still with a DB on the line of scrimmage).

As much as I like creating completely original formations I've discovered that it is very difficult to do except for offensive passing formations. Defenses are basically required to at least show presence across the field, and running formations on offense require s certain number of large bodies in a somewhat compact space.

I'd say that on defense Edge Nickel and Peregrine 3-4 are my only truly original formations, the rest are variations on common themes. This isn't a bad thing, it's just that most of the obvious ideas have been discovered. New ideas are most likely to succeed in my opinion if they take a successful idea and tweak it just a bit. Stuff that is both completely original and very successful is really a rarity.
pimpdaddypat Mon Jan 24, 2005 3:53 am
it may be unique ... but your uniqueness is maiking it less effective ... which means that it is less likely to be added to the guest playbook section ... why not just try out arks suggestions and see ... it cant hurt ... and you might find that you like it ... sure its good to be unique ... but what good is it when you get your ass kicked while doing it?
bobnoles Tue Jan 25, 2005 12:35 am re:
I agree with what you are saying....if Arkaein wants to try some variations, that is fine. I am just going to keep what I have for my own playbook as it has worked well for me.....if I am in a situation where I don't think the box is a good call, I can just call another formation.

No problem at all if you want to tweak it Ark........

Page 2 of 2: 1 2

Forum Index » Guest Playbook » Madden Defensive Formation: Box Protect