I would just like to add my voice in saying BRING BACK THE PLAYBOOKS.
Also, the reason cannot be because it makes the game too easy. If anyone really did get an answer like that from an EA representative then they're talking to us like 5 year olds. First of all, this is (or was) a completely customizable game. You can go and give your guy 99 everything, play on rookie, and adjust the Human and CPU sliders to whatever you want. With the game set like that aren't you going to win and set records everytime anyway? How does Undercuts or any other play create a more unfair advantage than that?
Now, in reality, I can't imagine that anyone here plays with settings like that. I keep good players on my team but I always keep my settings so that the game is HARD. Therefore, the too easy argument is nonsense.
Also, a call to arms.. since I'm sure we all want to push for playbooks in 2007 we should additionally push for specific improvements to the Custom Playbook feature. Here's some.
1. Let the receiver routes use more of (or ideally, the entire) field.
2. Allow guys in the backfield the options to fake handoffs, pitches, do reverses, option running, and have more blocking styles.
3. More blocking styles for the offensive line.
4. Add more "moves" for receivers.. like the hitch-and-go. Let us put nice spins, jukes, etc as waypoints in the route. Maybe a guy might be the fastest but if he just runs off the line making moves in single coverage he may be open.
5. Change the end of routes from what it is "<get open> and run around aimlessly" to something maybe you can control on the field or write into the play.
on the defensive side...
1. More types of zones.
2. Let us have some type of grid like on offense where we could have the defender run to a fixed point on the field and THEN perform an action.
So, theres my input. A venting session with some constructive ideas thrown in to be fair.