Forum Index » Guest Playbook » 4-4...my more versatile alternative to the 5-2
4-4...my more versatile alternative to the 5-2
OG Relapse Sat Jan 08, 2005 12:04 am 4-4...my more versatile alternative to the 5-2
[code]
------------x------------
--------------------------
--------------------------
---------x-----x---------
-x---x------------x---x-
-------x--x--x--x-------
[code]
its not really to scale, you put the four linemen out normally, than the OLB's just outside them, the MLB's shaded between the DEs and DTs, Saftey in the middle back deep
now...this probably seems like a run based defense, which it is. I play DE & DT and this is my schools base defense. it may seem limted against the pass with only 3 DBs, and it is susceptible to a deep ball, but is great against a two-wide. the LBs are spaced out enough, to provide shallow blanket coverage across the middle. I hated this when I first saw it, but what happened during the season, was people were forced to throw over the LBs and got picked alot. And with 4 LBs, theres no telling where the blitz will come from
as for a play? all four LBs in a hook zone, saftey in a deep zone, and corners in man coverage.
When your done playin' football, go play football
Arkaein Sat Jan 08, 2005 12:19 am
----------x----------
---------------------
---------------------
--------x---x--------
x---x-----------x---x
------x--x-x--x------
This sounds like something worth trying OG Relapse.
I thought I'd fix up your diagram a bit since your code tag didn't work, and I'd like you to verify that I got it right since I had to cut out extra spaces to get it down to 21 x 7 (just needed 21 x 6 in this case, unless the safety is supposed to be at max depth).
The CBs I put all the way to the outside, the OLBs have one square between their columns and those of the DEs, there is only one empty square between the DTs, and 3 squares between the MLBs. Look right?
OG Relapse Sat Jan 08, 2005 5:06 am
yeah, thanks for fixing the diagram
thas how its supposed to be
for a more run-based version you can just stack the line backers on the lineman
-x-x-x-x-
-x-x-x-x-
but I dont much fancy that
When your done playin' football, go play football
pimpdaddypat Sat Jan 08, 2005 6:08 am
looks interesting... this weekend i am drawing up some 4-4 defense that i will post on here
OG Relapse Sat Jan 08, 2005 8:17 am
I suppose the 5-2 is less susceptible to a deep pass though as it has an extra saftey...but having only two linebackers can make the middle of the field weaker to the pass drags, people coming out of the backfield, tight ends. It duppends on your depth at the defensive line, and your depth at linebacker...I also think I'm partial to the 4-4 because thats what my team (St Pete Green Devils) ran, and we were a buetiful defense...holding opponets to under 100 yards total offense in some games. I guess I need to...and am gonna make something to illustrate the finer points of the 4-4 and some plays... Ill post that up soon
http://www.monsterden.net/madden/52punisher-mirageblitz
^^^^ I like that play though alot
When your done playin' football, go play football
pimpdaddypat Sat Jan 08, 2005 4:34 pm
they are both made to stop formations with like 2 or less receivers. but yeh your right, it really depends on your O-line depth and LB depth as to which one you run. I personally run a 5-2 and a 4-4.
pimpdaddypat Sat Jan 08, 2005 4:35 pm
as to which is more versatile, im gonna have to say the 5-2. but im really talking about the verision i created. i modified the 4-3 to make it. what i did was i just scooted the linemen out and moved the MLB up to a NT position and move the OLBs to behind the DT's with one space in b/t them and the DT's. Then I just kept the secondary the same as the 4-3 secondary. the 5-2 is mainly for 2 WR formations. it stops the run VERY well. So the reason the defense that i created works well is b/c say you call 5-2 and the offense ends up running a formation with more than 2 receivers, then you can shift back into a 4-3 and have better pass coverage.
OG Relapse Tue Jan 18, 2005 10:08 pm
if they have TEs and RBs that are a big threat catching passes the 4-4 provides much better pass protection across the middle on slants, drags, ins, outs, flats, swings, ect. in a more run based formation, thats what kinda routes the'd be running anyway, not deep passes where you need the two safties deep.
what you made isnt a real 5-2 anyway, if you just moved up the MLB (unless you changed him to a DT), because you still have four linemen and three linebackers. if you changed him to a DT though, than it seems like a solid fifty front, but with a MLB in the middle, and the ends moved out and OLBs inside, it seems like the middle would be open to a dive from a wishbone type formation, or even an i form with a TE in motion.
i guess im buyist to the 44 though
When your done playin' football, go play football
pimpdaddypat Wed Jan 19, 2005 3:39 am
what would it matter if it were a MLB or DT in the middle spot right in front of the center. they would both be in the same spot so it wouldnt be different ... the only difference is their stances, the MLB doesnt get in a 3 point stance ... he stays up ... but as long as they are both in the same postion, then they would have the same effectiveness at stopping runs up the middle ... unless you just had a horrible MLB ... but even with a good DT to put in the middle, he still only gets like 75 or 80 tackles a year ... therefore, proving that it doesnt matter whether you put a MLB or DT in the noseguard position ... they will most likely have the same effect...
Forum Index » Guest Playbook » 4-4...my more versatile alternative to the 5-2