Forum Index » Guest Playbook » My New 5-2 Package

My New 5-2 Package

Poll: Does my formation work well for you?

Total votes: 9

Phate Mon Nov 15, 2004 5:30 am My New 5-2 Package
Well, I've been boasting about it for quite some time, and I've decided to create a package on the 5-2. I think you all will find that the plays included will help you stop teams that have been giving you a hard time.

Please, comment on both my plays, and how you think I did explaining them. I'm always willing to hear your feedback so I can improve.

Feel free to ask questions!

For the index:
http://www.clan-dfe.com/football/5-2/

For the complete package:
http://www.clan-dfe.com/football/5-2/5-2package.zip
I agree to these terms and am overor exactly 13 years of age.
Arkaein Mon Nov 15, 2004 10:24 pm Quick Thoughts
Haven't had a chance to try it out yet, but your formation looks pretty solid.

The one thing I question is (if I'm reading it right) your heavy use of man ocverage including by the safeties. This looks like it will be Monstrous 8) against the run but could give up some big plays against the pass.

If your opponent goes max protect and sends a WR deep down each sideline, it will be a 1-on-1 jump ball matchup. A bit risky. Do you have any plays where you mix in zone coverage? I'm using a lot of 2 Deep zone in the 5-2 I'm developing, which I feel is generally prudent for blitz heavy plays.
pimpdaddypat Tue Nov 16, 2004 12:54 am
the only thing im questioning is is there any way you could show exactly how to create the formation in the madden playbook creater, like which squares to put people in and what not? like a grid?
Phate Tue Nov 16, 2004 1:29 am Re: Quick Thoughts
Arkaein wrote:
Haven't had a chance to try it out yet, but your formation looks pretty solid.

The one thing I question is (if I'm reading it right) your heavy use of man ocverage including by the safeties. This looks like it will be Monstrous 8) against the run but could give up some big plays against the pass.

If your opponent goes max protect and sends a WR deep down each sideline, it will be a 1-on-1 jump ball matchup. A bit risky. Do you have any plays where you mix in zone coverage? I'm using a lot of 2 Deep zone in the 5-2 I'm developing, which I feel is generally prudent for blitz heavy plays.


Agreed. I'll work on some zone plays for better passing prevention this weekend. I'm waaaay too busy during the week, as basketball just started for me.

EDIT: Also, while putting defensive backs into zone coverage may reduce deep threats, I'm questioning its ability to stop short passes.

For example, if I was in a Slot Right I Formation (5 down linemen, one reciever on the line to the left, one reciever in the slot to the right, two running backs), I would just send my recievers deep to keep the DBs away, then send my running backs to the flats and make short passes to either side. There's no one there to immediately cover them, resulting in pretty good yard gainage offensively.

If I had to choose between the risks, I'd say that as long as your DBs are more athletic than their opponents, a jump ball against a reciever probably will be easier to defend. Also, on all of the man coverage plays I showed you guys, there is immediate and constant pressure on the quarterback. He has to make a throw very quickly, or else he is going to get sacked.

As far as I'm concerned, if the recievers are athletic enough to beat the DBs before the quarterback quickly throws, as well as catch a hurried throw, then they freakin' deserve the touchdown, because as far as I'm concerned, it's close to impossible for them to do it.

Last edited on Tue Nov 16, 2004 5:37 am; edited 1 time in total.

I agree to these terms and am overor exactly 13 years of age.
Phate Tue Nov 16, 2004 1:29 am
pimpdaddypat wrote:
the only thing im questioning is is there any way you could show exactly how to create the formation in the madden playbook creater, like which squares to put people in and what not? like a grid?


I'll work that in when I add zone plays in this weekend.
I agree to these terms and am overor exactly 13 years of age.
Phate Thu Nov 18, 2004 5:21 am
Ok, I found a little time and made a couple changes to the document. The newest version is now available. Go to the same link.
I agree to these terms and am overor exactly 13 years of age.
pimpdaddypat Fri Nov 19, 2004 3:08 am
thanx a million
pimpdaddypat Sun Nov 21, 2004 5:16 pm
what formation do you modify to create this formation? or do you not modify a formation to create it?
Phate Mon Nov 22, 2004 12:19 am
pimpdaddypat wrote:
what formation do you modify to create this formation? or do you not modify a formation to create it?


I don't modify one, but I'm sure you could have a ton of success if you modified it from another formation.

I'll experiment with modifying formations when I get Madden 2005.
I agree to these terms and am overor exactly 13 years of age.
drm61779 Mon Nov 22, 2004 8:05 am
You are doing an excellent job with your write up, keep it coming so I can see if there is anything I can steal and add to my scheme :wink:

I run a 50 defense that me and my friend have been developing for 3 years now that started out as just a base 5-2-4 and has expanded to a 5-3-3(short yardage) 5-1-5(nickle) 5-0-6(dime) and a 5-4-2(goal line) look. I have found that with the 5 man line you can do pretty much whatever you want with the other 6.

Where my front differs from yours is I spaced my line out more, I have a NT head up over the center and then 1 space between each of them, having the line spread out almost eliminates any outside runs and helps create space for the LB's and Safties to blitz through.

Also I don't like to create my defensive formations by modifying other formations, because if you modify a 3-4 or a 4-3 into the 5-2 and use BnR the safties will try to move back to thier original positions, besides all you really lose is the ability to shift the Line and LB's, all of the coverage audibles work except for the fake blitz that brings the safties up to the line and you really don't need that anyway.
pimpdaddypat Mon Nov 22, 2004 9:17 pm
one thing i notice about your formation is that you have all your number one players on the offenses left side and all your number 2 players on the offenses right side which seems odd to me when offenses tend to be "right handed" meaning that they mostly run to the right side which is where you have all your number 2 people ... just a thought though
Phate Tue Nov 23, 2004 3:52 am
pimpdaddypat wrote:
one thing i notice about your formation is that you have all your number one players on the offenses left side and all your number 2 players on the offenses right side which seems odd to me when offenses tend to be "right handed" meaning that they mostly run to the right side which is where you have all your number 2 people ... just a thought though


That was probably just me being lazy and not thinking about that.

Besides, a good coach is random, so when playing good teams you should be ready for anything.
I agree to these terms and am overor exactly 13 years of age.
pimpdaddypat Tue Nov 23, 2004 7:29 pm
another thing is ... try modifying the 4-3 defense into the 5-2 ... thats what i did and it works really well ... what you do is you just widen the linemen and then make the middle linebacker the noseguard and keep the secondary how it is ... that way if the offense comes out in a formation with more than 2 recievers you can shift back into a 4-3 that is more suited for covering formations like that ... and it gives you more play variety because you can confuse the defense by creating plays where the middle linebacker (now the noseguard) drops back into pass coverage so right before the offenses hikes the play you shift out of the 5-2 into the 4-3 and the middle linebacker can drop back into pass coverage ... or you dont have to shift at all ... and if you do shift the middle linebacker back ... you can add more variety to your blitzes .... so it is usefull to modify an old formation ... and if you dont like to shift ... then simply dont shift and its all the same
Phate Wed Nov 24, 2004 2:39 am
pimpdaddypat wrote:
another thing is ... try modifying the 4-3 defense into the 5-2 ... thats what i did and it works really well ... what you do is you just widen the linemen and then make the middle linebacker the noseguard and keep the secondary how it is ... that way if the offense comes out in a formation with more than 2 recievers you can shift back into a 4-3 that is more suited for covering formations like that ... and it gives you more play variety because you can confuse the defense by creating plays where the middle linebacker (now the noseguard) drops back into pass coverage so right before the offenses hikes the play you shift out of the 5-2 into the 4-3 and the middle linebacker can drop back into pass coverage ... or you dont have to shift at all ... and if you do shift the middle linebacker back ... you can add more variety to your blitzes .... so it is usefull to modify an old formation ... and if you dont like to shift ... then simply dont shift and its all the same


Quoted for truth!

In the next update I make for the word document, I'll talk about how to modify it out of the 4-3.
I agree to these terms and am overor exactly 13 years of age.

Forum Index » Guest Playbook » My New 5-2 Package