Forum Index » Monstrous Madden Playbook » Issues with existing plays in Madden 2005
Issues with existing plays in Madden 2005
Arkaein Tue Aug 10, 2004 10:03 pm Issues with existing plays in Madden 2005
Hey everyone, I just got my copy of Madden 2005, and have started bringing in my 2005 playbooks (in progress) that I started developing in Madden 2004 and started releasing on my site yesterday. While the playbook editor is mostly the same, and the game mechanics are similar enough that most plays should work out all right, there are a few differences to discuss.
The most blatant change is that custom routes can no only go forward 9 squares instead of 10, which affects several of my older passing plays. I probaby won't change the plays on this site, for the most part just shortening the routes by one step and possibly compensating horizontally as well will keep basically the same route.
The new U Bacon formation has an issue with Red Sea Counter. This running play worked excellently for me in Madden 2004. However, the handoff mechanics are one of the biggest changes apparent in 2005, and this play takes a bit longer to get going than in 2004. My QB gets tackled before making the handoff in most cases. I'll probably have to make some changes here, either change it from a counter or change the pull right block to a standard run block.
Some of my formations have motions slightly different than last year. Because this depends on the initial formation that is modified as well as game version, this is hard to keep consistent. I'm going to try and keep giving motion and Playmaker suggestions for my plays, but in some cases your results may not match what I am able to do. Sorry, but there's not much I can do about this, except test all of my new plays for Madden 2005. Everyone will have do make there own adjustments for older plays, as I really don't want to rewrite each play for every new version of Madden.
My defenses seem all right so far. There seems to be a bit more variability from play to play, which is probably due to improved AI and slight tweaks to game mechanics.
So far that's all I've got concerning my personal playbook in Madden 2005. Any other issues that are spotted, good or bad, post `em here for discussion. I'll be making more updates as I install more of my playbooks.
pimpdaddypat Wed Aug 11, 2004 3:12 pm
I was just wondering if in U Bacon you could shift the fullback from cheated to the right side to cheated to the left side under the left guard or tackle ... I haven't actually gotten around to creating the formation but I wanted to suggest a play that would work if you can shift the fullback like I asked... I haven't gotten the 2005 version yet so I don't know how well it will work in it but I thought I might ask you, Arkaein, if you could try it because I have a formation quite similar to your U Bacon that I run my play in. The only difference between your formation and mine is that instead of a second tightend to the right I have a second wide reciever stacked right under the wide reciever to the left (like a twins set to the left except that they are stacked on top of each other), so I thought my play might work in your formation as well... so let me know if you can shift the fullback to under the left guard or tackle and if you can then I will tell you the play... thanks
-Patrick-
Arkaein Wed Aug 11, 2004 6:41 pm Modified formation
Well, I don't plan on making any permanent changes to U Bacon (because in addition to the 2 plays I've release I have several other that I've developed), I would be interested in any variations you might have, and I'm sure other in the forums would like to hear them as well.
pimpdaddypat Thu Aug 12, 2004 5:48 pm
Well I just wanted to say that if you can motion the full back to under your left guard or tackle and then back to under the right guard or tackle then I know I play that might work well for you.
Have both guards pull right. Have the rest of the linemen just run block except for the #2 TE who is off the line to the right. Have the #2 TE lead block to which ever way works best for you. Have the full back lead block outside right. Have the Tailback do a counterstep outside right (or sweep if that works better for you). And just have the backside reciver run block or you can back him block offtackle right so that he heads up field to block the freesafety (once again, do which ever works best for you). So this play is basically a counter outside / sweep right with both guards pulling right to help block outside. Give it a try Arkaein and tell me what you think.
pimpdaddypat Thu Aug 12, 2004 5:52 pm
Oh I forgot to mention what you do with motioning the fullback. IF YOU CAN, motion the fullback from under the left tackle or guard to under the right tackle or guard. This should cause the defense to shift AWAY from the side you are running the play to. Then when the defense is done shifting away, shift your fullback back to the right and hike the ball. The full back should be able to get back to the right before the defense can. This causes the defense to be on the opposite side that you are running to while your fullback is on the right side, able to block outside still, which creates a big hole outside in the defense. The only time this play doesn't work is if they blitz someone through the hole where the guards are pulling so watch out for that.
kingfeej Sat Aug 14, 2004 4:11 pm
A side note, my all time fave running play of yours, the allmighty diamond wing delay sweep, seems to have this problem as well, and even if you do manage to get the handoff given, I get closed on so fast I havent gained anything more than 5 yards.
the one cheif rocka don't front.
pimpdaddypat Sat Aug 14, 2004 5:48 pm
Has anyone tried the play I posted above to see if it works in 2005?
Arkaein Sun Aug 15, 2004 9:21 pm Finally tried it
PDP, I finally tried this play and while it looked very promising under the playbook creator it unfortunately fell down in practice mode (All Pro difficulty).
I tried both with my standard U Bacon as well as a modified one with FB moved left. I just kept the ouside TE run blocking rather than lead blocking any direction.
It basically has the same problem that Red Sea Counter has, namely that the line cannot hold back the defensive rush long enough for the counter step handoff when two linemen are pulling. The QB was tackled in the backfield about 15% to 20% of the time, and the RB dropped for a loss about 40% to 50% of the time. The rest of the time the back managed to get outside with blockers in front and had successful runs, but it just wasn't consistent enough. I'd recommend some tweaking once you get your copy of 2005, because I do see promise.
----
BTW, kingfeej, thanks for the heads up on Delay Sweep. I haven't gotten around to reimplementing my older playbooks yet, but I will soon make at least one personal playbook including the best of my 2003 and 2004 offenses, so I may get a chance to update Delay Sweep in the near future. This could be part of another transition guide, though trying to update all of my plays each year (even without modifying the original webpages) seems like a losing battle as my library of plays grows each year.
pimpdaddypat Sun Aug 15, 2004 10:37 pm
I thought that might be the case with my play after I read what you said about the changes in 2005. But, once I get my copy I will do some tweaking with my blocking and let you know about it.
kingfeej Tue Aug 17, 2004 2:20 am
On the other hand, some plays, especially the pass plays in your Axe formation and one I created in the same form work seemingly doubly well, probably due to how tight the corners cover your guys, and how that formation works by breaking a reciever outside. My third string reciever is #1 for WR of the Year thanks to Flare and Dart alone!
the one cheif rocka don't front.
pimpdaddypat Tue Aug 17, 2004 2:16 pm
It seems as though in 2005 the defense has become better against the run. As a result, they are probably worse against the pass, especially if they are blitzing more. So all pass plays should still work as well if not better than they did before, as kingfeej has told us.
Arkaein Tue Aug 17, 2004 3:15 pm pass defense
I disagree with the defense not being as good against the pass, the defense is almost certainly better here, at least in the hands of a person (CPU on its own is not significantly tougher).
Run defense seems tougher up the middle, which is where the best runs occurred in 2004, but seems to be a bit more opened up around the outside, reminiscent of Madden 2002-2003, in my opinion. I think the balance here is the best ever in the modern Madden era.
pimpdaddypat Wed Aug 18, 2004 7:16 pm
Well I guess I really don't have any real say in this because I don't even have 2005 yet.
Forum Index » Monstrous Madden Playbook » Issues with existing plays in Madden 2005