Forum Index » Guest Playbook » 4-3 Edge

4-3 Edge

Poll: do you think this defense would work in the NFL? (if not, explain in a reply)

Total votes: 9

ace007 Sun Jul 18, 2004 6:48 pm 4-3 Edge
words can't describe how good this defense is, so I'll just tell you how to make it and you can see for yourself. It's basically just a form of the 4-3 regular. All you hafta do is:
-move the SS up one block,
-move the corners up to the line of scrimmage,
-move the OLB's out one square.

now you've gotta make the most important changes.....the personnel changes:
-put your #1 and #2 corners at the safety positions,
-put your SS as the MLB,
-put your OLB's to the corner positions,
-substitute MLB's for you OLB's.

you can only use one play out of this formation..."Cover 2" with one slight change
-have the SS (who is now in the MLB position) play deep zone.

what do you have now?
-instead of wasting your CB's speed by limiting them to the flat, you got your OLB's there who can defend against the outside run and go against bigger TE's and RB's that usually run routes out to the flat.
-the corners and SS (who is the key to this defense becuase he should have the size to play the run and the speed to cover deep) playing deep thirds agianst the pass.
-the MLB's roaming the middle of the field for the crossing routes and there also right there to stuff the run. ALSO, they can contain the QB from scrambling out of the pocket.

this play is good enough to use on every down in every situation (except for goaline or 3rd and IN) but i'd stilll reccommend mixin it up a bit. if you can think of another play to use outta this formation, let me know....
"It's always too soon to quit"
-Rudy
pimpdaddypat Tue Jul 20, 2004 1:59 pm
i don't think it would work in the nfl simply because there's a good bit of weaknesses to it ... consider a spread formation with 4 or 5 wide recievers or a power formation with two tightends and 3 running backs ... with 4 or 5 recievers, it's likely that you will find some holes in your zone ... see, when playing against a zone defense, the personel that is at each defensive position is not a factor. the key is to just find holes in the zone or send 2 or more guys into 1 zone so that the defensive player covering that zone is unable to cover everyone in it ... with a doulbe tightend and 3 running backs formation, the power this formation would eat up the middle of your defense ... with only a strong safety there the offense would run iso-leads up the middle all day long and get positive yardage, and thats even if the offense only had a mediocre string of running backs. consider if someone like ricky williams or jerome bettis was back there, an excellent power running back, you would be on your way to a big loss ... just my opinion though
ace007 Tue Jul 20, 2004 2:36 pm
you gotta good point, thats why strong safety is the key to this defense. you need someone in there like roy willliams, john lynch, or sean taylor who is big enough to defend the run but also fast enough to play a deep zone. and you're prolly right about the 5 wrs set formation...in that case, i go man to man and have a six man rush so the qb hasta get the ball off quick for minimal gain or else he'll get sacked.
"It's always too soon to quit"
-Rudy
Arkaein Tue Jul 20, 2004 5:36 pm My thoughts
An intersting variation to one of the most fundamentally sound plays in the basic playbook. Pimpdaddypat has started a good critique already, so I'll just add to it.

First of all, this play ought to be rock solid against any runs outside the tackels, or guards for that matter, due to the spread LB presence. However, in addition to the SS safety replacing the MLB weakening the D slightly up the middle, as pdp pointed out with lead plays as an example, quick handoffs up the middle might also break through due to the outside LBs being move a step further outside.

Second, the LBs in flats coverage worsen what was already the biggest hole in the original play, the curl zone area behind the flats. A true CB has good recoverage speed to react to passes behind his zoen, a LB does not. I would run fades, outs and deep curls behind these flats zone all day against this play, once I had it figured out.

Third, there are only 3 DBs! 2 Deeps zones are decent deep coverage, but if I send 3 WRs on deep routes, one will not be covered. 2 outside streaks and a post to the middle, watch the safeties (er, cornerbacks I guess here), then throw. Of course this was an issue with the original play as well, but illustrates why it probably shouldn't be used against 3 or more WRs.

Fourth, no FS. When testing the play with the Packers, I had Marcques Anderson in instead of Darren Sharper. Not exactly ideal. Of course this can be dealt with fairly easily.

That about covers it. I hope this doesn't come off as too harsh, I think this play could make a really good change of pace and create confusion. Decent pass rush, good run defense, and great zone coverage against the short passing game. I just think that the quest for the "perfect" defense will have to go on a little bit longer :?
Arkaein Tue Jul 20, 2004 5:37 pm One more thing
Also forgot to say, I've moved this topic to the Guest Playbook Forum. Everyone, please try to post your topics to the correct forums in the future. Thanks.
SPEAKER-X Wed Jul 21, 2004 2:31 am
Sup Ace, I think this is a well coached play, it can be a terror in red zone sisuations because of the short field (it protects U from the deep ball). :roll: but I would use it sparingly a Good Balla reads the flat protection once U spread the LBs out and would attack with the run or pass it's still Cover 2 no matter how U DIsQuise it :lol: ! A well timed corner or out route will always beat the Safety & Corner on Cover 2
Some People Will Do Or Say ANything, In Order To Not, MAN the F#CK UP and Play You!!!
ace007 Wed Jul 21, 2004 3:54 am
thanks for the feedback guys.....to me, it sounds like the biggest flaw of this defense seems to be the SS in the MLB position. what i now do to counter this is shift the defensive line in tight to protect the SS (on running downs) which forces the opponent to run outside to my linebackers. i also shift the linebackers in a lil' bit if they're really tryin to jam it up the middle.
also, i might not of made this clear enough, but i have the SS playing a deep zone so he has deep middle 1/3 and the corners have deep outside 1/3. occasionally on 3rd and long when i know the offense will be goin deep, i'll move the SS back a bit so he'll be in better position, but most times i don't need to
....you guys should give it a try....i think you'll be surprised how well it works :wink:
"It's always too soon to quit"
-Rudy
Arkaein Wed Jul 21, 2004 4:18 pm My mistake
You're right, I missed the part where the SS plays deep zone. That definitely solidifies against any deep pass.

There are still gaps along the sideline (though smaller), and directly over the middle with the wide spread LBs, but this does sound like a more solid play than I originally thought.

Soundes like good advice to slide the line in against the run as well, though with the SS dropping deep there will still be gains up the middle.
ace007 Wed Jul 21, 2004 6:39 pm
yeah i think i'm gonna move the MLB's in more to better defend against the run and protect directly over the middle like you guys said.....thanks

ace
"It's always too soon to quit"
-Rudy
SPEAKER-X Wed Jul 21, 2004 7:18 pm
all it's cover 3 :o ,cool. I'll try this play thx Ace!
Some People Will Do Or Say ANything, In Order To Not, MAN the F#CK UP and Play You!!!

Forum Index » Guest Playbook » 4-3 Edge