Monstrous Madden Playbook Forums

[TURF SAVAGE]

we should have ..sticky for:

"guest defensive plays/formations"
"guest offensive plays/formations"
"guest special teams plays/formations"

in the guest forums, a thread shou;d be a "whole playbook", not just one play....the stickies would keep all the one play posts in one location

so everyone wont make a whole thread for one play clogging the board....


jsut an idea

[Abbo55]

It's a good thought. I don't know if Arkaein will think so though.
_________________
Either email or PM me for a playbook list. Note: they are REAL playbooks, not Madden ones.
Draftnik55@yahoo.com
Check out my site! Free playbooks & message boards! http://sitekreator.com/abbott/main_page.html

[Arkaein]

I appreciate the thoughts TURF SAVAGE, but I disagree with your suggested changes.

First of all, the more arbitrary rules or guideline I have on posting, there more they will be broken simply because people aren't aware of them. I made these forums simple, with just 5 forums in all so that it would be easy for people to put things in the right place, and new members still post in the wrong forum once in a while.

Second, this would lead to extremely long topics. I hate skipping to the end of 20 page topics on some other forums. Any topic at the top of a list in any forum should be mostly new discussion in my opinion.

Third, I think single plays are absolutely worthy of their own posts. Not many people have entire playbooks that they want to post directly in the forums, much less even a whole formation full of plays.I want to encourage deep discussion of analysis of formations and plays, like what I do with my own material. It's easy enough to add new plays in the formation later as replies under the same topic. Yes, some people will post new plays in a formation under a new topic, but I'd rather search through a few short topics than one gigantic topic with about 100 replies.

Finally, as you've probably noticed, there really isn't enough traffic on this site for anyone to hog the board. You'd need to make a dozen new topics to push anything very far down the page in any forum.
_________________
Arkaein

[skee420]